Ok, I really had no plans of talking about this, but what are the rules if a site is doing duplicate content on our site? This is what was done... 1. Old site, since 2,000, more than 18k backlinks, high PR. 2. Cloaked content by user agent detection. 3. All his 8000+ indexed pages show my site's content cloaked by user agent. Displayed to Googlebot. 4. Cache dates were as early as March 18. Obviously this is a separate site from any of the competitors entries. Thus you cannot really say who is doing this. But definitely one of the competitors and I do not like pointing fingers are people that I really don't know who is responsible since I believe that is wrong. Maybe some of you have noticed already that his site is already ranking. So what's our rules? Obviously duplicate content will pull my site down. But if you plan to disqualify people who implemented this, then that is the problem. Who implemented it. Anyway, it's just a contest and it's just $1k. This #1 ranking is not for any of my SEO clients anyway.